Ethan Chislett and the Kaizer Chiefs Transition: Former Teammate Nick Gindre Backs the Midfielder Despite Slow Start

Kaizer Chiefs’ 2024 off-season was marked by several bold recruitment decisions, none drawing more curiosity than the signing of Ethan Chislett — a technically gifted attacking midfielder returning to his country of birth after spending nearly his entire football career in the United Kingdom.

Sixteen games into the new campaign, Chislett has yet to make his official Amakhosi debut, raising questions among supporters about his readiness, adaptation, and long-term role at Naturena. But while some fans may be concerned, former AFC Wimbledon goalkeeper Nick Gindre — who also enjoyed a spell in the South African top flight — believes the midfielder is on the right track and simply needs time to fully adjust.

In an interview with KickOff.com, Gindre offered insight into why Chislett deserves patience, why Chiefs signed him for a reason, and why his background in England should not be underestimated.

Siwelele FC Coach Lehlohonolo Seema Breaks Silence on Failed Pursuit of Neo Maema

A Journey That Came Full Circle: Chislett’s Path Back to South Africa

From Durban to the UK

Born in Durban, Chislett didn’t follow the typical development route of many South African players. He left the country as a child and built his football foundation in England — a system known for its competitiveness, discipline, and physical demands.

His journey took him through various levels of English football, including:

Aldershot Town (National League)
AFC Wimbledon (League One)
Port Vale (League One)

These leagues, although not Premier League or Championship level, are still exceptionally competitive and known for producing players with strong tactical discipline and high work ethic.

Arrival at Naturena

When Kaizer Chiefs announced his signing, supporters were intrigued. A South African-born midfielder with European training and tactical schooling? For many, Chislett represented a refreshing profile — someone capable of bringing structure, intelligence, and work rate into a midfield that has struggled with creativity and consistency in recent seasons.

Yet, 16 matches later, the midfielder has managed only two appearances on the bench and no minutes on the pitch.

Nick Gindre’s Vote of Confidence: “No Doubt About His Ability”

Nick Gindre, a retired goalkeeper of Argentine origin, understands Chislett’s journey better than most. Like Chislett, he also played for AFC Wimbledon before moving to the PSL, where he represented AmaZulu and Mpumalanga Black Aces. His experiences give him a unique perspective on the transitional challenges players face when crossing from English football into the South African game.

Speaking to KickOff.com, Gindre offered nothing but praise and reassurance:

“If you play at that level in England, then you are a good team player who can take directives from the coach and there shouldn’t be any doubt at all about your abilities as a footballer.”

This line alone speaks volumes. League One and League Two football are not easy environments. They demand:

Tactical discipline
Stamina
Quick decision-making
High-intensity work rate
Structure and consistency

In other words, players don’t make it in those leagues by accident. As Gindre puts it, the competition is fierce, and progress is earned — not handed out.

Sundowns vs Lupopo: A Rare First for the Brazilians as CAF Champions League Returns

Understanding the Transition: Why England-to-PSL Is Not a Straight Line

Different Football Cultures

One of Gindre’s key points is the massive contrast between English football and the South African game. The UK football environment is tightly structured:

Every role is clearly defined
Players make fewer touches on the ball
The game is fast, tactical, and physical
Creativity is often secondary to structure

In contrast, South African football — especially in midfield — leans toward flair and flexibility:

More time on the ball
Dribbling and individual creativity
Improvisation
Ball retention and rhythmic build-up play

This shift is not always easy for returning diaspora players.

“When you come here as a midfielder, it is challenging because there is more freedom and players spend more time on the ball.”

This freedom can be difficult for players trained in structured systems. Creativity becomes a requirement rather than a luxury.

Adjustment to Speed and Awareness

Gindre highlighted that the PSL demands:

Faster transitional awareness
Quicker reactions in tight spaces
Adaptation to a less aggressive — but more technical — environment

This difference can impact positioning, timing, and decision-making.

Injuries Slowing His Integration

Another important factor: Chislett’s injuries.

“It is unfortunate he has been slowed down by injuries.”

Injuries can derail acclimatization, fitness progression, tactical integration, and confidence. Chiefs appear to be taking a patient, deliberate approach to ensure he returns fully ready.

Why Chiefs Signed Him: A Calculated Move, Not a Gamble

Gindre made it very clear that Kaizer Chiefs do not sign players without thorough evaluation:

“You can’t play for Chiefs without them having checked who you are, so they know who they signed.”

At a club as scrutinized as Chiefs, recruitment undergoes:

Detailed scouting
Video analysis
Background research
Style-of-play compatibility studies

Chiefs have not brought Chislett in to fill numbers. They brought him because they believe he offers something different — and potentially transformational — to the squad.

Zambia Make Late Call-Up for Sekhukhune United Star Toaster Nsabata Ahead of Bafana Bafana Clash

Where Chislett Fits in Chiefs’ Long-Term Vision

A Different Type of Midfielder

Chiefs have often struggled to find midfielders who blend work rate with creativity and tactical intelligence. Chislett fits this modern profile:

Comfortable between the lines
Technically sound
Hard-working off the ball
Good at pressing
Disciplined in defensive structure
Able to link play and transition from defense to attack

This is the type of player coaches trust to maintain shape, tempo, and tactical discipline.

A Potential Solution to Chiefs’ Creativity Issues

Kaizer Chiefs have long lacked a consistent creator. While Chislett is not a classic No. 10 with flashy tricks, he offers:

Progressive passing
Vision
Quick combinations
Timing into the box
Set-piece quality

Once integrated, he could complement ball carriers and attacking wingers.

Why Fans Should Be Patient

Chislett’s slow introduction to the team doesn’t indicate failure. Instead, it signals that the club wants him fully settled physically, mentally, and tactically before handing him minutes.

Gindre believes this approach is deliberate:

“I believe Chiefs is making sure that when he makes his appearance then he is ready in all aspects.”

Chiefs have learned from mistakes of rushing foreign or returning players into matches before they are acclimatized. With Chislett, they seem to be preparing carefully for long-term success, not short-term pressure.

Conclusion: A Player Worth Waiting For

Ethan Chislett’s journey is one of homecoming, adaptation, and potential. While he has yet to debut for Kaizer Chiefs, those who understand the complexities of transitioning from English football to the PSL know that his time will come.

Nick Gindre’s assessment serves as a timely reminder: